from the pass —
Menu photos
A few dishes from the current card — tap any shot to view larger.
1 / 2
Explore the Lucy Blue Pizza OTR menu featuring delicious build-your-own pizzas, classic sandwiches, fresh salads, and refreshing beverages. Experience exceptional service and mouthwatering New York-style slices in Cincinnati’s vibrant Over-the-Rhine district.
Lucy Blue Pizza OTR in Cincinnati offers a fresh take on classic American and Italian flavors, with a menu designed to satisfy every pizza lover. Their standout feature is the Build Your Own (BYO) pizza, available in 12" and 16" sizes, plus a gluten-friendly 11" cauliflower crust option. Each pizza starts with Lucy’s original red sauce and dough recipe, topped with freshly shredded mozzarella, baked to perfection.
Beyond pizza, the menu features crowd-pleasing appetizers like crispy Chicken Tenders with Honey Mustard or Lucy’s Ranch, house-made Meatballs in al dente red sauce, and fresh Classic Caprese with ripe tomatoes and basil drizzled with balsamic glaze. They also offer a variety of side sauces, including a spicy Lucy Classic Pizza Sauce and several dressings to complement salads and sandwiches.
What truly shines is the balance between familiar comfort and thoughtful creativity. The pizzas are praised for their perfect crust and quality ingredients, capturing the essence of a genuine New York-style slice with a local twist. Friendly service and a bright, inviting atmosphere complete the experience, making Lucy Blue a must-try for anyone seeking flavorful, handcrafted pizza in the heart of Cincinnati’s OTR district.
A few dishes from the current card — tap any shot to view larger.
Build Your Own delicious Lucy Blue pizza!
Build Your Own delicious Lucy Blue pizza!
Build Your Own *If 1/2 toppings, please specify in the 'special instructions' which toppings need to be on the same half please
Lucy's original red sauce & dough recipe topped with shredded mozzarella, cooked to perfection! Where it all started in 2001 on 12th street downtown
Lucy's original red sauce & dough recipe topped with shredded mozzarella, cooked to perfection! Where it all started in 2001 on 12th street downtown
BBQ Sauce, Roasted Chicken, Red Peppers, Red Onion, Sweet Corn, Black Olives, Mozzarella
BBQ Sauce, Roasted Chicken, Red Peppers, Red Onion, Sweet Corn, Black Olives, Mozzarella
Olive Oil, Garlic, Mozzarella, Provolone, Parmesan & Feta Cheeses, Sprinkled with Fresh Parsley
Olive Oil, Garlic, Mozzarella, Provolone, Parmesan & Feta Cheeses, Sprinkled with Fresh Parsley
Homemade Buffalo Sauce, Roasted Chicken, Celery, Red Onions, Mozzarella & Cheddar Cheese. Topped with Scallions & a Ranch Drizzle
Homemade Buffalo Sauce, Roasted Chicken, Celery, Red Onions, Mozzarella & Cheddar Cheese. Topped with Scallions & a Ranch Drizzle
Marinara Sauce, Bacon, Green Peppers, Pineapple & Mozzarella
Marinara Sauce, Bacon, Green Peppers, Pineapple & Mozzarella
Olive Oil, Garlic, Spinach, Black Olives, Green Olives, Mozzarella, Feta Cheese, Topped with Roma Tomatoes
Olive Oil, Garlic, Spinach, Black Olives, Green Olives, Mozzarella, Feta Cheese, Topped with Roma Tomatoes
Olive Oil, Garlic, Fresh Basil, Roma Tomatoes, Mozzarella
Olive Oil, Garlic, Fresh Basil, Roma Tomatoes, Mozzarella
Olive Oil, Garlic, Mushrooms, Mozzarella, Goat Cheese, Sprinkled with Fresh Parsley
Olive Oil, Garlic, Mushrooms, Mozzarella, Goat Cheese, Sprinkled with Fresh Parsley
Pepperoni, Sausage, Onion, Green Peppers & Mushrooms
Pepperoni, Sausage, Onion, Green Peppers & Mushrooms
Spicy Asian Sauce, Chicken, Celery, Scallions, Red Peppers, Mozzarella & Sesame Seeds, Topped with Grated Carrots
Spicy Asian Sauce, Chicken, Celery, Scallions, Red Peppers, Mozzarella & Sesame Seeds, Topped with Grated Carrots
Marinara Sauce, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Red Peppers, Roma Tomatoes, Black Olives, Mozzarella, Sprinkled with Fresh Parsley
Marinara Sauce, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Red Peppers, Roma Tomatoes, Black Olives, Mozzarella, Sprinkled with Fresh Parsley
Served with Honey Mustard or Lucy's Ranch
Sliced Tomatoes, Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Basil with Balsamic Glaze
Homemade with Dipping Sauce
Homemade with Al Dente (red sauce)
Mixed Greens, Cran Raisins, Toasted Almonds, Goat Cheese, Served with Raspberry Vinaigrette
Romaine Tossed in Creamy Caesar Dressing, Topped with Parmesan Cheese & Diced Tomatoes
Mixed Greens, Cucumber, Carrots, Tomato, Cheese & Croutons
Dressings: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Ranch, Caesar, Italian, Blue Cheese
Extra dressing
Extra dressing
Extra dressing
Extra dressing
Extra dressing
Steakhouse Beef, Homemade Marinara or Mushroom Sauce, Provolone Cheese, Pickles, & Onions on a Honey-Butter Hoagie Bun
Homemade Meatballs Simmered in Marinara Sauce with Mozzarella on a Hoagie Bun
A Warm Sandwich with Sliced Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone Cheese, Tomato, Onion, Banana Peppers, Lettuce & Your Choice of Mayo or Italian Dressing
Baked Breaded Chicken Breast with Lucy Classic (spicy) or Lucy Fresh (mild) Marinara Sauce & Provolone on a Honey-Butter Bun
Breaded chicken breast with homemade buffalo sauce, lettuce tomato & onion
Extra dressing
Extra dressing
Extra dressing
Extra dressing
Extra dressing
Came down with my husband from Dayton for a short 4 day trip and ate the last night. The pizza was the best we ever had. It was the Hawaiian pizza can’t wait to try the other ones if we ever come back to town.
Opening hours, the full address and the best way to get there are all on the restaurant page. Booking policies differ from place to place — so call ahead, or simply walk in.